Skip to content

Understanding the Bargain Element in Equity Compensation

The bargain element, also known as the compensation element or spread, is a crucial concept for employees with equity compensation packages. This article explains what it is, how it's calculated, and its tax implications.

business documents on office table with smart phone and digital tablet and graph financial with social network diagram and man working in the background-1

What is the Bargain Element?

The bargain element is the difference between the fair market value (FMV) of a stock and the price you pay to acquire it through your equity compensation. This difference represents a form of compensation from your employer and has important tax implications.

Calculating the Bargain Element

The basic formula is: Bargain Element = Fair Market Value - Exercise/Strike Price

Example 1: Stock Options: Let's say you have stock options with the following details:

  • Strike price: $10 per share
  • Current market value: $25 per share
  • Number of shares: 1,000
  • Bargain Element = ($25 - $10) × 1,000 shares = $15,000

This $15,000 represents the immediate gain you would realize upon exercising your options.

Example 2: Restricted Stock Units (RSUs): For RSUs, the bargain element is typically the entire value of the shares when they vest, since you don't pay anything to acquire them.

  • Market value at vesting: $50 per share
  • Number of RSUs vesting: 200 shares
  • Purchase price: $0
  • Bargain Element = ($50 - $0) × 200 shares = $10,000
Tax Implications

Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs)

  • The bargain element is taxed as ordinary income in the year you exercise the options
  • Your employer will typically withhold payroll taxes
  • The bargain element is added to your W-2 income

Incentive Stock Options (ISOs)

  • No ordinary income tax at exercise (but the bargain element may trigger Alternative Minimum Tax)
  • If you hold the shares for at least 1 year after exercise and 2 years after grant, the entire gain qualifies for long-term capital gains treatment
  • Early disposition (selling before holding period requirements) results in a "disqualifying disposition" where the bargain element becomes ordinary income

RSUs

  • The bargain element is taxed as ordinary income when the shares vest
  • Typically subject to automatic withholding
  • Reported on your W-2
Planning Considerations

Tax Timing

  • Consider exercising options over multiple tax years to spread out the tax burden
  • Be aware of upcoming vesting events and plan for the tax impact

Cash Flow Management

  • Calculate the tax impact before exercising options
  • Consider setting aside funds for taxes, especially for ISOs where AMT might apply

Market Risk

  • Remember that the bargain element is taxed even if the stock price later declines
  • Consider immediate sale strategies to lock in gains and cover tax obligations
Special Situations

Early Exercise: If your company allows early exercise of options:

  • No immediate bargain element if you exercise when FMV equals strike price
  • Consider filing an 83(b) election to start the capital gains holding period
  • Risk losing money if you paid more than the eventual FMV

Private Companies

  • FMV typically determined by 409A valuations
  • May need to wait for a liquidity event to realize value
  • Consider exercise timing relative to expected exit events
Record Keeping Best Practices

Maintain detailed records of:

  • Grant documents
  • Exercise prices and dates
  • FMV at exercise
  • Tax elections filed
  • Holding periods
  • Sale information

Understanding the bargain element is essential for making informed decisions about your equity compensation. Consider consulting with a financial advisor or tax professional to develop a strategy that optimizes your equity compensation while managing tax implications.